Sherwin-Williams vs. PPG Paint: Which One is Right for Your Project?

Written By Tom Kim

When tackling a home improvement project or a large-scale commercial job, choosing the right paint brand can be crucial for both the quality and longevity of your work. Now that Kelly-Moore Paints have left the Austin market, two of the leading names left in the our market are Sherwin-Williams and PPG Paints. Both brands offer a range of products that cater to different needs, but they have distinct characteristics that can make one more suitable than the other for certain types of projects. Let's break down the differences between Sherwin-Williams and PPG Paints.

1. Company Background and Reputation

Sherwin-Williams:
Founded in 1866, Sherwin-Williams is a major American paint company with a reputation for producing high-quality paint and coatings. With over 4,000 stores nationwide, the brand has become synonymous with premium quality and exceptional customer service. Many professional contractors trust Sherwin-Williams for residential and commercial projects alike, known for its consistency, durability, and color options.

PPG Paints:
PPG Industries, established in 1883, is another long-standing player in the paint industry, originally focused on glass but later expanding into coatings. PPG is a global brand, providing paint products for a wide variety of markets including automotive, aerospace, and architectural applications. PPG Paints are often associated with high-performance finishes and competitive pricing, especially for commercial and industrial use.

2. Product Range and Innovation

Sherwin-Williams:
Sherwin-Williams is known for offering a broad spectrum of paints and finishes, catering to residential, commercial, and industrial needs. Some of their most popular lines include:

  • SuperPaint – A great all-around performer with durability and good coverage.

  • Duration – Known for its excellent durability and coverage, ideal for high-traffic areas.

  • Emerald – Their premium line, offering superior washability, stain resistance, and a rich finish.

  • ProMar 200 – A popular choice among contractors for commercial use, offering durability at a reasonable price.

Sherwin-Williams is also at the forefront of eco-friendly innovations, with their zero-VOC products like Harmony, catering to the growing demand for sustainable building materials.

PPG Paints:
PPG offers a wide array of products, from consumer-grade paints to professional and industrial finishes. Popular lines include:

  • PPG Timeless – Known for its one-coat coverage and long-lasting durability.

  • PPG Manor Hall – A premium paint line offering excellent stain and scrub resistance.

  • PPG Break-Through! – A unique, fast-drying formula perfect for both interior and exterior surfaces, including difficult substrates like concrete or vinyl.

  • PPG Pittsburgh Paints – A go-to for professional painters, providing a balance of quality and affordability.

PPG's innovations shine particularly in the commercial and industrial sectors, with coatings designed for high durability and performance in demanding environments.

3. Price Comparison

Sherwin-Williams:
Sherwin-Williams is generally considered a premium brand, which is reflected in its pricing. Paint lines like Emerald or Duration come with a higher price tag but are often considered worth it for their exceptional coverage, durability, and long-lasting color retention. Many professional contractors and DIYers willing to invest in quality prefer Sherwin-Williams for high-end projects.

PPG Paints:
PPG Paints are typically more competitively priced than Sherwin-Williams, especially for their mid-tier products. While they do have premium lines, PPG is often seen as more accessible for budget-conscious consumers or larger-scale commercial projects where price is a key factor. For those looking for value without compromising much on quality, PPG provides a solid alternative.

4. Coverage and Durability

Sherwin-Williams:
One of the reasons Sherwin-Williams is a preferred brand for many professionals is its superior coverage. With many of their products, fewer coats are required to achieve a rich, uniform finish. This results in both time and cost savings in labor and materials. Durability is another strong point, particularly with lines like Emerald and Duration, which are resistant to fading, stains, and wear over time.

PPG Paints:
PPG Paints also deliver good coverage, but some users note that additional coats may be necessary compared to Sherwin-Williams, especially with lower-tier products. However, their top-tier products like PPG Timeless and Manor Hall offer excellent durability and stain resistance, making them competitive with Sherwin-Williams in terms of longevity.

5. Color Selection and Customization

Sherwin-Williams:
Sherwin-Williams boasts an extensive range of over 1,500 colors, with the ability to customize shades further. Their ColorSnap system helps homeowners and designers find the perfect color combinations, and the brand offers excellent color-matching services. If you’re seeking a precise color or a trendy shade, Sherwin-Williams is well-equipped to meet your needs.

PPG Paints:
PPG Paints offers a strong color selection as well, though their range may not be as expansive as Sherwin-Williams. PPG has a unique collaboration with the Voice of Color program, providing consumers with trending colors and helpful design tips. Their color-matching capabilities are solid, but Sherwin-Williams tends to lead in color variety.

6. Availability and Customer Support

Sherwin-Williams:
With thousands of stores across the U.S., Sherwin-Williams is highly accessible for both professional contractors and DIY homeowners. Their staff is often praised for offering helpful advice, especially for those new to painting. Many customers appreciate the one-on-one consultations available in their stores.

PPG Paints:
PPG Paints are available through a variety of retailers, including Home Depot, PPG Paints stores, and independent dealers. While they don’t have the same large retail footprint as Sherwin-Williams, PPG’s products are still widely accessible, especially through major retailers. Customer service is generally strong, though the experience can vary based on the store or retailer.

Conclusion: Which Paint is Better?

Choosing between Sherwin-Williams and PPG Paints ultimately comes down to your project’s needs and budget.

  • If you’re looking for premium quality, excellent coverage, and a wide color selection, and you don’t mind spending a bit more, Sherwin-Williams is likely the better choice. It’s especially ideal for residential projects or high-traffic areas where durability is a must.

  • On the other hand, if you’re working on a larger-scale or commercial project and price is a primary concern, PPG Paints offers a competitive balance of performance and value. Their industrial products also stand out in more demanding environments.

Both brands are trusted in the industry, so whether you choose Sherwin-Williams or PPG, you’ll be working with paint that professionals rely on to deliver great results. Give us a call for a free estimate if you’re a homebuilder, house flipper or commercial developer needing painting services in the

Tom Kim